Expert advice in minutes not days. Register it's free and ask your first question now.
ReachBack is our free community help desk for construction professionals. A library of high-quality questions from real users with answers delivered and curated by a panel of industry experts.

4,240 questions

4,426 answers

538 comments

34,652 users

Register its Free

Download here

NEC ECC: Can Clients insist on Contractor's using NEC Contracts in their supply change?

0 votes
57 views
Food for thought....

Can Clients insist on Contractor's using NEC Contracts in their supply change?

I often read about the benefits of the Contractor utilising back-to-back NEC Contracts with their supply chain, whether sub-contractors, suppliers or professional services, but have never seen this requested as a contractual requirement..

Does anyone know of significant pitfalls in making back-to-back contracts a contractual requirement in the main contract?

Would I be correct in assuming that his would be done as a Z-clause?
asked Sep 12 in NEC3 Secondary X, W & Y options by Obelix1970   5 11
   

2 Answers

0 votes
For me no significant downsides as, as a Contractor, I would want to be as back to back as possible. Having said this, I think the biggest legal risk is often ignored by lawyers (believe it  or not) and that is the risk (almost certainty) of not operating the contract as written leading to breaches of contract.

So while lawyers might want an full ECS as it is back-to-back legal with the ECC, the reality is that for a small subcontract, neither the Contractor or Subcontractor will operate it as written, so both will be in breach at some point. And if both a re consistently in breach, then it can lead to a big ball of spaghetti to unwind. So for smaller subcontracts, I suggest  using the short form.
answered Sep 13 by Jon Broome (23,720 points)  
Thanks, Jon.
0 votes
Just to add/compliment to Jon's answer - it is legally very difficult/not possible to impose a form of contract, however you can "strongly encourage". If anything other than an NEC contract is proposed it has to be accepted by the Project Manager, so if I was a Contractor that would be one less acceptance I can avoid by using NEC down the line as well.

As a Contractor I can not think why I would not want to be anything other than back to back.
answered Sep 13 by Glenn Hide (30,990 points)