Expert advice in minutes not days. Register it's free and ask your first question now.
ReachBack is our free community help desk for construction professionals. A library of high-quality questions from real users with answers delivered and curated by a panel of industry experts.

4,200 questions

4,375 answers

511 comments

34,509 users

Register its Free

Download here

NEC3 ECS: Costs for Unproductive Working

0 votes
160 views
Our Subcontractor has effectively been stopped from working due to a Technical issue that our designers are struggling to find an answer for. They havent been served a stop notice. They are effectively sat around doing nothing whilst our guys answer their queries. They have not been able to fully mitigate the costs as they have little work for their team to move on to, (I have witnessed their empty factory). Compensation event has been submitted for the additional time which is fine, but their costs are for the full time they have worked on our Subcontract and the unproductive time. Is this correct or do we only pay for costs directly related to our Subcontract? How do i know they arent billing all of their employers for this unproductive time? Thanks
asked Oct 9, 2016 in NEC3 Compensation Events by Steve  
   

1 Answer

0 votes
It would have been a little more helpful here if you had indeed given them an instruction as to what to do given you are aware of the situation and their predicament. You could have sat down with them to discuss the options available - could they have deployed the guys elsewhere or even released them somehow but then there is no guarantee that you will get the same certified/qualified guys back.

It depends on which option you are working on as to how much actual cost evidence you get but not unreasonable to ask for evidence here that the guys are all being kept on ready for your works to restart. Had they done anything different that may have cost even more if it delayed things further whilst they re-mobilised.

I think the Contractor should have taken the lead here as to what should happen/have happened, and then the Subcontractor needs to provide evidence of the labor cost they are/will incur.
answered Oct 9, 2016 by Glenn Hide (29,340 points)  
Glenn, unfortunately I picked up this Subcontract mid delay and it was too late to issue a stop notice as the designers didnt envisage taking so long to reply to TQ's. They have moved guys (who are all staff not Contractors) on to other works but that only covered a few hours a week. Timesheets have been submitted but they can show what they want them to show, which is 20 hours a week unproductive working. We are using Option A.