Expert advice in minutes not days. Register it's free and ask your first question now.
  • Register
ReachBack is a free web based knowledge capture and sharing service, a help desk and library of 1000+ high-quality questions and answers, delivered and curated by a panel of industry experts.

3,970 questions

4,110 answers

417 comments

33,459 users

Register its Free

Download here

JCT: Can one item be omitted from contract to get cheaper price and if so is the contractor entitled to claim oh&p

+2 votes
We have a JCT minor works contract with a value of £286,000 after we signed the surveyor acting for the client omitted the supply and fit of the windows valued at £17,400 and gave the works to a cheaper company can we claim for oh&p on the £17,400 ?
asked Oct 30, 2015 in General by Ray  
recategorized Oct 30, 2015 by Glenn Hide
   

1 Answer

0 votes
Under JCT works can be omitted as there is an express variation clause allowing omissions (without an express clause then there is no right).

However that right cannot be exercised to remove works and give them to another company - it can only be used to omit them altogether.

The contract you signed gave you the right to carry out all the works for the price agreed. You can bring a claim for breach of contract as your employer cannot omit works to get them cheaper elsewhere. Your damages are to put you in the position you would have been in had you carried out the works ie your profit on those works.

Whether you can claim overheads would depend on whether you can properly link those only to the omitted works.
answered Nov 9, 2015 by Sarah.Fox (280 points)